Filing Chapter 11 Bankruptcy in lieu of posting a supersedeas bond

By Law Office of J. R. SmithPublished 2 min read

Published April 22, 2024. This article is general information, not legal advice, and may not reflect later developments in the law.

Filing a Chapter 11 bankruptcy does not automatically permit an appealing party to forego posting a supersedeas bond when appealing the decision of a federal district court.1 However, it can create a scenario where the need for a supersedeas bond is obviated.

In the case In re Fox, the court held that the mere fact that a Chapter 11 petition had been filed to permit the debtor, without the necessity of posting an appeal bond, to obtain a stay of an adverse judgement was not “cause,” in itself, for dismissal of the bankruptcy case.2

Another case, In re Muskogee Environmental Conservation Co., also noted that the filing of a bankruptcy petition and the imposition of the automatic stay had obviated the necessity for a supersedeas bond.3However, courts differ on whether filing a bankruptcy petition to avoid the posting of a supersedeas bond indicates bad faith.4

The court in the case In re Surgical Associates, Inc. declined to adopt a per se rule that filing a bankruptcy case as a substitute for posting a supersedeas bond constitutes bad faith.5 Instead, the court considered the totality of the circumstances, including the debtor’s ability to post such a bond and their financial situation.6

This sentiment is echoed in the case In re Hyatt, where it was held that the fact that an individual Chapter 11 case was largely a two-party dispute between the debtor and dominant creditor, which the debtor had commenced as an alternative to posting a $3.5 million supersedeas bond, did not, without more, constitute “cause” for dismissal or conversion of the case on a “bad faith” theory.7

Therefore, while a Chapter 11 bankruptcy can permit an appealing party to avoid posting a supersedeas bond, this is not an absolute rule and is subject to scrutiny and interpretation by the courts, especially with respect to the debtor’s motives and financial circumstances.

Footnotes

  1. In re Fox, 241 B.R. 224, 227 (B.A.P. 10th Cir. 1999) ↩

  2. Id. ↩

  3. In re Muskogee Env’t Conservation Co., 236 B.R. 57, 66 (Bankr. N.D. Okla. 1999) ↩

  4. In re Hyatt, 479 B.R. 880, 892 (Bankr. D.N.M. 2012) ↩

  5. In re Surgical Assocs., Inc., No. 13-10081-R, 2013 WL 1176233, at *4 (Bankr. N.D. Okla. Mar. 21, 2013) ↩

  6. See Muskogee and Surgical Associates cases for totality of circumstances analysis. ↩

  7. See In re Hyatt, footnote 4. ↩

Questions about this topic?

Book a consultation to discuss how it applies to your business.